Talkin’ Tokens! The Highs and Lows of Token Design

With the new Empower Jace mechanic from Reality Fracture, we’ve got tokens on the mind! From format-defining tokens to one-off nostalgia cards, we dive deep into the world of tokens.

Scryfall gallery of cards mentioned

Topics and Tidbits

  • if amass and clues had a baby
  • giving abilities to planeswalkers
  • “empower jace 2” isn’t quite “draw a card”
  • loyalty card
  • many other custom attempts at token planeswalkers hit roadblocks
  • what does it take to make grafting abilities onto planeswalkers work
  • so much of a token’s value is just being an object… can be sacrificed, counted, tapped, etc
  • cards that are fun to play but you wouldn’t want to design them
  • kicker jace
  • token versions of famous cards
  • the loyalty costs of various size creatures
  • the design pleasure of finding a new repeatable technology vs the satisfaction of creating a single standalone card
  • the “token hater” section of the pod
  • gripe 1: mass tokens are too good at blocking
  • “well, SOME of us want the game to end”
  • playtesters losing the will to live
  • gripe 2: it’s hard to represent tokens besides 1/1s and treasure/food without a tracker
  • the wide diff between playing a cube with curated tokens and a cube where you have to track the weirdest tokens for rares from 10 years ago
  • trying to remember a token that was created 7 turns ago, but discreetly
  • gripe 3: having to create a lot of custom paper tokens for custom design
  • gripe 4: finding perfect token art for custom sets (ok this one is niche)
  • being so experienced at magic that you know how to compensate for the parts you don’t like
  • drawing your own tokens
  • the duelist’s fallen empires token sheet
  • square tokens: not good for tapping!
  • hobbit’s big food token
  • gripe 5: token heavy sets need to weaken bounce and don’t work with flickering
  • gripe 6: tokens require saying “nontoken” in rules text and blurs “whenever a card” cases
  • passing the syr konrad test
  • dodging tokens all together with bar cube
  • equipment mechanics that create a creature to start with
  • how about creatures that make equipment tokens?
  • final fantasy wizard tokens
  • big creature that makes a little token vs little creature that makes a big token
  • providing different incentives for making 1/1 tokens
  • the preposterous 1/4 token
  • the sneaky power of 1/2 reach spider spawning tokens
  • “what did foundations do?”
  • TONS of tokens in foundations?!
  • Wizards must think tokens are totally fine for new players
  • making copy tokens of different objects, yuck
  • temporary tokens like mobilize
  • how good a solution is Decayed?
  • how useful is the tech of creating tapped tokens
  • tapped clues. he wants to make tapped clues.
  • would it be worth requiring tapping for equipment?
  • murmur saga token (chapter 2+3: add C)
  • the value of land tokens vs the hassle of them
  • token boat vehicle 4/3 crew 2
  • tokens with exalted
  • do you just win the game if you have 3 exalted enchantments?
  • when do we get the next “empower X” card?
  • only 4 years from 2030
  • Jallaba shoutout
  • anime food recs

Posted

in

by