At What Cost!

Juliet’s new game has us picking costs from cards, but we don’t have all our options available! Can we get a mono-red double striking defender? Abzan direct damage? WB creature stealing?

In this game, Khord and Tim were told they have to draft some number of costs and colors.

They didn’t know what game they were playing. After about 10 picks they were told to stop, and here’s what they each got.

It turns out the game is this: You get a card, and have to use your mana values and colors to pick the cost of the card, then provide some justification.

Topics and Tidbits

  • secret pre-show draft
  • the challenge: set mana costs for these cards using only your portion of the MV/colors as options
  • the memnite of walls
  • ways to design your seventh wall in a set
  • changing rarity and adding types is ok
  • could red have “your defenders can attack”?
  • what is the discount you get for giving defender to a double striker?
  • nerf the rules text but buff the flavor text
  • thorny plant wall
  • reveal your deck, discard your hand
  • just how good would your payoffs need to be to make two mana “cascade, discard your hand” work
  • delirium and “only high MV cards” is a hard thing to make happen early
  • rhino boys
  • moa talk
  • juliet’s Dragon’s Maze Jumpstart remix
  • haven’t had a white 3/2 for 2 mana at common yet
  • Avatar Jumpstart’s plethora of french vanilla creatures
  • using creature type to add more colors to a card
  • vedalken sigil corp
  • Rhys’s group of elves
  • giving up on costing 0
  • weird drafting strats paying off
  • filterland tech coming to artifacts
  • powerstones live on
  • ooze vs weird
  • using set symbols to balance cards
  • how good is a creature that can never trade?
  • is ward 2 or ward pay 3 life better on an equipment?
  • surprise instant wrath
  • surprise voc-gal reference
  • destruction timmy
  • all eyes on tim
  • when the extra text doesn’t add much to the mana cost
  • the power of permanent indestructible in commander vs in draft
  • onboard (or “on grave”?) tricks in commander vs draft
  • famous andrew sherman quotes
  • thassa’s oracle: prerelease terror (?)
  • you, too, have the power to ruin a commander game
  • join You Make the Pack!
  • innovative weekend splitting

Here’s all the starter cards (in grey) and then Khord and Tim’s versions!


Posted

in

by